S.F. Chronicle
"That's the hardest vote I ever had," said Tim Kurkjian of ESPN.com, who picked Lincecum first. "You could make a great case for Lincecum and an equally great case for Santana. I asked a stats friend of mine to find a Cy Young winner for me, and he came back with Brad Lidge, and you can make a compelling case for Brandon Webb. "I voted for Lincecum because, to me, he was the most dominant pitcher in the league and the best. He played for a lousy team and went 18-5, and that's remarkable."